It is going to be hard thing to except, but to give my arguement a chance, you have to remove the celebrity aura surrounding this average looking girl.
To start , look at the pictures of her attached below. Pay particular attention to the comparisons of what she looked like a few years ago, before she dramatically changed her natural image (ie where have all the freckles gone?) Compare her pictures with a few actual good looking women that I found searching the internet for 2 minutes. Here is a good example. Out of my high school class of 100 (about 50 girls), I can think of 8 girls who are clearly better looking. Assuming I had a representative sample that would mean that almost 20% of the female population looks better than her. Still not convinced? Take a walk down any busy street in Manhattan. It will take about 1 second for you to find a handful of better looking women. Also, just watch the videos and hopefully her internal ugliness and lack of talent will sway your vote